StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

End of Life Choices - Research Proposal Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper examines the moral and ethical concerns surrounding euthanasia, otherwise known as mercy killing or assisted suicide, clarify the meaning of the term, present arguments for the practice and conclude with a recommendation to resolve the issue…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
End of Life Choices
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "End of Life Choices"

 End of Life Choices Euthanasia, otherwise known as mercy killing or assisted suicide, has been a controversial subject for many centuries. Proponents of the practice believe that individual freedoms of choice that exist in life also extend to the end of life. They also argue that the sentiment of humane treatment afforded animals that are terminally ill or injured and are suffering should be given to humans as well. Opponents suggest that euthanasia is a ‘slippery slope’ that would allow increasing instances of coerced suicide, family members pressuring the elderly not to postpone their inevitable demise for financial reasons. In addition, the practice would lessen the urgency to develop new medicines designed to prolong life. Those who oppose the practice on religious grounds argue that it is ‘playing God’ therefore sinful. Health care professionals cite the Hippocratic Oath which forbids them from carrying out this procedure. This paper will examine the moral and ethical concerns surrounding euthanasia, clarify the meaning of the term, present arguments for the practice and conclude with a recommendation to resolve the issue. Euthanasia describes a situation in which a terminally ill patient is administered a lethal dose of medication, is removed from a life-support system or is simply allowed to die without active participation such as by resuscitation. A doctor’s involvement in the procedure could be to either prescribe a lethal dose of drugs with the express intent of ending a life or by intravenously inserting a needle into the terminal patient who then activates a switch that administers the fatal dose (Naji et al, 2005). Assisted suicide by physicians and non-physicians has been legal in Switzerland since WWII. In addition, three organizations within the country have been established to aid terminally ill patients. They provide patient counseling as well as the drugs for use in the procedure. Lethal injections, however, are not allowed. The unusual situation in Switzerland holds that assisted suicide is allowed as long as a physician is not a part of the process (Hurst & Mauron, 2003). Euthanasia has been legal in Belgium since 2002. Each case must be reviewed by two physicians before the procedure is carried out by either ingestion or injection. In The Netherlands, euthanasia has been legal for four years but has been tolerated for two decades. The guidelines for physicians handed down from the government include; “the patient must be suffering unbearably and have no hope of improvement, must ask to die and the patient must clearly understand the condition and prognosis (and) a second doctor must agree with the decision to help the patient die” (“The Fight”, 2004). Proponents of euthanasia are concerned with human suffering. Many diseases such as cancer cause a lingering and excruciatingly painful death. Watching a loved one as they wither away from the disease eating away at their organs is tough enough on family members, but to see them suffer even when drugs are administered is unbearable not to mention what the patient must endure. This emotionally and physically torturous situation is played out in every hospital, every day of the year but serves no purpose. To many, it is unimaginable to allow anyone, for example, a sweet old grandmother who has spent her life caring for others to spend the last six months of their life enduring constant pain, unable to control bodily functions, convulsing, coughing, vomiting, etc. The psychological pain for both the family and patient is unimaginably horrific as well. If grandma were a dog, most all would agree that the only humane option would be to ‘put her to sleep.’ U.S. citizens are guaranteed certain rights but not the right to ‘die with dignity.’ This right is not prohibited by the Constitution but by religious zealots who evidently put the quality of life of a dog above grandma’s. Patients suffering from Alzheimer’s may not suffer physical pain but endure a different type of pain and usually for a long period of time. Alzheimer’s is a degenerative disease causing the patient to ramble incoherently and lose their memory. Many people who led vibrant, active and purposeful lives are remembered by their family members in this state (Messerli, 2007). Proponents of euthanasia also argue that the time of health care professionals, of which there is a perpetual shortage, especially nurses, could be used in a more productive manner such as on patients who are not certain to die. Numerous studies have established that understaffed medical care facilities provide a diminished quality of care to all. Those that could benefit from quality care sacrifice their health for those that are suffering a slow, agonizing and undignified death. The cost of health care overall would be reduced as people with no hope of survival no longer drain the available resources and manpower which translates to lower insurance rates. Health care costs have skyrocketed over the past decade and as the ‘baby boom generation’ ages, this problem will increase exponentially which does not benefit anyone. “Consider the huge cost of keeping a dying patient alive for several months. You must pay for x-rays, lab tests, drugs, hospital overhead, medical staff salaries, etc. It is not unheard of for medical costs to equal $50,000-100,000 to keep some patients alive” (Messerli, 2007). It’s a burden on everyone especially on the family that must pay it. Elderly, terminal patients do not want to be responsible for the financial ruin of their children, but do not have the option to call for an end. Euthanasia also allows for organs such as livers, hearts and kidneys to be harvested for transplant into otherwise healthy individuals with a potential for many more years of life. While it may be emotionally morbid to think of things in such terms, in a world where medical miracles can occur everyday that permit another human being a chance at a more fulfilling life, these considerations must also be made. In the real world, it is more likely that an individual will opt first to save the young child from an oncoming bus rather than an old man. By the same token, it seems incredible that today’s society would opt to allow a child to die so that a terminal patient might be forced to live a few more agonizing months. This, in effect, is the result of not allowing people to die with dignity. Many terminally ill people choose to end their own life to evade the previously discussed detriments of a terminal illness. Suicide rates are by far the highest among the elderly population for this reason. “If these people are going to commit suicide, which is better, controlled, compassionate doctor-assisted suicide or clumsy attempts like taking sleeping pills, jumping off a building, or firing a bullet into one's head?” (Messerli, 2007). The unfortunate reality is the majority of people in the U.S. die a ‘bad death.’ A study determined that “more often than not, patients died in pain, their desires concerning treatment neglected, after spending 10 days or more in an intensive care unit” (Horgan, 1996). Most Americans (53 percent) believe euthanasia to be not only compassionate but ethically acceptable and 69 percent would support the legalization of euthanasia according to a Gallup Poll conducted in 2004 (“Public Grapples”, 2004). Opponents of a doctor-assisted suicide law often cite the potential for doctor abuse. However, recent Oregon and UK laws show that you can craft reasonable laws that prevent abuse and still protect the value of human life. For example, laws could be drafted that requires the approval of two doctors plus a psychologist, a reasonable waiting period, a family members’ written consent and limits the procedure to specific medical conditions. Works Cited “(The) Fight for the Right to Die.” (September 27, 2004). CBC News. Retrieved February 29, 2008 from Horgan, John. (May 1996). “Right to Die.” Scientific American. Retrieved February 29, 2008 from Hurst, Samia A. & Mauron, Alex. (February 1, 2003). “Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia in Switzerland: Allowing a Role for Non-Physicians.” British Medical Journal. Vol. 326, N. 7383, pp. 271-273. Messerli, Joe. (March 4, 2007). “Should an incurably-ill patient be able to commit physician-assisted suicide?” Balanced Politics. Retrieved February 29, 2008 from Naji, Mostafa H; Lazarine, Neil G. & Pugh, Meredith D. (September 1981). “Euthanasia, the Terminal Patient and the Physician’s Role.” Journal of Religion and Health. Vol. 20, N. 3, pp. 186-200. “Public Grapples With Legality, Morality of Euthanasia.” (July 13, 2004). The Gallup Poll. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“End of Life Choices Research Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/social-science/1544804-assignment-for-my-sociology-class-euthanasia
(End of Life Choices Research Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1544804-assignment-for-my-sociology-class-euthanasia.
“End of Life Choices Research Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1544804-assignment-for-my-sociology-class-euthanasia.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF End of Life Choices

Essentials of Nursing Law

end of life Care Subject: Professor: February 24, 2013 end of life Care Introduction Nursing professionals are bound by ethical and legal standards.... The research delves on end of life nursing care.... The research delves on nursing roles during end of life situations.... hellip; Nursing professionals must comply with end of life ethical and legal standards.... Discussion Nurses play a vital role in the patients' end of life care....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Liverpool Care Pathway

The review finding recommends the Liverpool Care Pathway to be phased out and be replaced by a personalised end of life care plan that takes good care of the life of a patient who is facing imminent death (Department of Health, 2013).... Replacing the LCP to a personalised end of life care plan may not resolve the controversies if the same transgressions persist.... In that context, this paper aims to objectively review the literature and explore the challenges that contributed to its failure in order to accurately consider the future development of the recently recommended personalised end of life Care Plan....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Legal and Philosophical Aspects of Consent

Research studies have confirmed that patients went information about their illness and End of Life Choices (McSkimming et.... Although technological advances in health care bring extended and improved quality of life, the ability of these technologies to prolong life beyond a meaningful point has raised ethical issues, especially in "nothing more can be done" patients.... Denial on the part of the patient and family members about the seriousness of terminal illness has been a barrier to discuss about end-of treatment options (Kubler-Ross, 1969)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Concepts of Blame and Retribution

He needs professional medical care for the rest of his life and will not be able to work again.... Changes occurring in Health care delivery and Medicine are the result of social, economical, technological, scientific forces that have evolved in the 21st century.... Among the most significant changes are shift in disease patterns, advanced technology, increased consumer expectations and high costs of health care....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

Decisions at the End of Life

Studies have conformed that patients want information about their illness and End of Life Choices (McSkimming et.... Decisions at the end of life Introduction: Medical profession today is 'Accountable' to the society .... One of the most difficult realities the doctors face is that, despite efforts and good care, some patients will die, either due to the nature of the diseases like Cancer or AIDS or due to developments related to patient's age and health conditions. … Although, technological advances in health can bring extended and improved quality of life, the ability of these technologies to prolong life beyond a meaningful point has raised ethical issues, especially in "nothing more can be done" patients....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Waterhouse Friderichsen

Therefore, the paper has two sections; description of the pathophysiological systemic condition and end of life debate.... This paper describes the pathophysiological changes that occur in Waterhouse Friderichsen and ethical issues surrounding the end-of-life for persons affected by this condition....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Good Quality End-of-Life Care Removes the Need for Euthanasia

As apparent, the practice of euthanasia presents a pessimistic moral view to the care-giving obligations when treating On the other hand, the end-of-life practice can be regarded as an optimistic ideology used in medical practices in order to continue caring for patients in their final days/hours, offering them temporary relief from the physical pain.... In the current times, multiple end-of-life treatment processes, such as palliative care and curative care among others are commonly enacted as an alternative step to euthanasia, which faces frequent ethical obligations (Rachels, 1975)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Colorectal Cancer Risk Factors

… Case study – Colorectal cancerPatient profileGiovani Carboni, a 56 year old man, has a market garden in a rural township.... Mr.... Giovani's wife and family drove 30km to take him to the nearest hospital because of his deteriorating health....  Subjective Case study – Colorectal cancerPatient profileGiovani Carboni, a 56 year old man, has a market garden in a rural township....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us