StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Levels of War and Just War Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Levels of War and Just War Theory" states that nations might embark on a “just war” that is not just because the nation's rulers are lying about what the other nation is doing.  Because of the drawbacks of the theory, it uses to analyze war without some sort of bias is limited…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Levels of War and Just War Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Levels of War and Just War Theory"

Levels of War and Just War Theory War can be analyzed on several levels, each of which brings a different perspective to the causes and effects of war. These three levels are the international, state, and individual levels of analysis. Although these perspectives all make strong arguments as to their usefulness, none is really satisfying alone. This is because each seems to miss out vital clues as to the causes of war. The best way to use these three levels of analysis is not by selecting one and ignoring the other two, but by using all three to explore different aspects of a war. Another theory that can be used to talk about war is the Just War theory, which attempts to explain how to fight a war properly from the moral high ground. However, while some parts of Just War theory are useful the tool can ultimately be used to come up with excuses to declare war. Furthermore, it is really a tool for use by governments interested in war, and is not particularly useful for actually analyzing the wars themselves. The individual level of analysis usually seeks to explain political issues in terms of individual people. Everything that happens is more or less because of what individual people do, and so this level of analysis can be used to figure out why people act the way they do and what the consequences of their actions are. In terms of political science, these people are usually not just everyday citizens of countries but the individuals who are in charge of them, like presidents, kings, generals, or prime ministers. When talking about war with the individual level of analysis, though, looking at individual soldiers actions can also be telling. The individual level of analysis tends to suggest that war is brought about entirely for personal reasons. For example, World War II could be said to have been started purely because of Adolf Hitlers hunger for power, and because of his own mental issues regarding his own inferiority. Likewise in Medieval History it could be argued that most of the wars were just because the kings wanted more land and more people under their rule. This type of analysis seems to have some bearing on reality, but it ignores larger problems like natural resources and the global power structure. Additionally, many individuals are completely ignored by this, and it suggests that the only reason anything happens in history is because of specific people who are in power. Although individual analysis would also be interested in the actions of specific soldiers in the heat of battle, their actions would not be relevant when talking about the outbreak of war itself, unless it was in cases where one person accidentally insulted or shot somebody from another country, and that set off a war. Since this level of analysis seems to ignore well over 99% of the worlds population, it seems to not be the best way to discuss the outbreak of war. When looking for causes of war on the national level, the most common culprits are things like national security or lack of resources. When viewed from this level, the actions of individuals do no matter. It is only the driving forces behind nation-states or social structures that is considered. So a nation might go to war because it is worried about what another nation is planning to do, or because they need more oil, or more land, or any other natural resource that is scarce where they currently exist. On the other hand, the war might be a preventive measure aimed at keeping another nation or social group in check before they attack. Going back to World War II, Americas entry into that war can be understood on the national level. Initially the US was not planning on getting involved in the war because it was happening all the way over in Europe and there was no threat to their people. However, when Japan got involved and bombed Pearl Harbor, the US government decided that an Axis victory in Europe or Asia would in fact have a devastating effect on the United States as well. Likewise, most of Europes getting involved is because the various nations were afraid that Hitler would manage to control all of Europe, and would then initiate human rights abuses on many levels. Like the individual level of analysis, national interpretations do seem useful. Again, though, they seem to be missing some of the facts, and when there are in fact purely personal reasons for going to war these are ignored because they are not something that the entire nation or social system is involved in. An additional problem with the state level of analysis is that governments are not always up front about their real reasons for doing things. So that if someone was to read a governments version of the causes of a war, that person would be unable to tell if the government was telling the truth about its causes or whether they were trying to put a good spin on their involvement. The international level of analysis is useful when discussing current political events, but its use in talking about wars is mostly an extension of the state level. World War I, as opposed to WWII, is a good example for international analysis, because its occurrence was largely a result of various treaties that all the nation-states at the time had with each other. Because so many countries had alliances that meant they would wage war on enemies of their allies, what might have been just a regional conflict became a huge battle that engulfed most of Europe. This is mostly an extension of the state level of analysis in terms of war because it assumes that nations are the only powers in existence and ignores the individual. As can be seen, then, these three levels of analysis are best used all at once, and not one at a time. Each level has different things to say about the outbreak of war, but what they have to say is not necessarily contradicted by the other two levels. To get a truly complete understanding of why a war happens, the best method would be to explore it from the individual level, the state level, and the international level all at once. Another theory that is used to discuss wars is Just War theory. This theory tries to set up rules or at least guidelines for when war is a valid option. What this means is that just attacking somebodys country because they are different from you is not allowed. Before you could declare war, you would have to have a good reason, like the other country murdering hundreds of thousands of its own citizens, or sabotaging your countrys means of feeding its citizens. Although Just War Theory is a useful tool for a nations rulers, it is not particularly useful when discussing war from a political science point of view. This is because its rules are not set in stone anyway, and a nation could theoretically argue that a war is just when a different nation might completely disagree. Furthermore, nations might embark on a “just war” that is not just because the nations rulers are lying about what the other nation is doing. Because of the drawbacks of the theory, its uses to analyze war without some sort of bias are limited. However, it can still be useful, if you wish to compare national differences that might have had some role in causing a war. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Political Science - war Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Political Science - war Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1743007-political-science-war
(Political Science - War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Political Science - War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1743007-political-science-war.
“Political Science - War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/politics/1743007-political-science-war.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Levels of War and Just War Theory

Vietnam- the American roll in that conflict

Dwight D Eisenhower, in 1954, helped to elaborate upon this doctrine of containment and expands upon it by discussing what has since become known as the “domino theory”.... This domino theory asserts that once a given nation within a particular region as a communist government and stated, then a domino effect will be felt throughout the region; allowing other nations to be weakened and ultimately fault of the influence that a single foothold of global communism can have within a particular region....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

World War II as a Just War

just war theory is actually a collection of moral considerations which limits the devastations caused by warfare.... hellip; Out of all the wars which took place in this century, the Second World War is considered to be the only occasion where one side of the conflict could be justified as following the criteria required for fighting a 'just war'.... This essay would validate this claim that the war fought by the 'Allies' was a just war, by describing the true nature and criteria required to name a war as a 'just war'....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Contrasting the Horrors of War Within Birdsong and Journeys

The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the varying horrors of war as they are seen in both… War plays an important role on many levels of humanity in both pieces.... The elements and consequences of war are seen in a physical, mental, and emotional sense throughout these works.... In this, the idea of war is made real to the reader through the virtual body count.... The reader is continuously reminded of how horrific this particular war was as most of the readers would not have experienced this set of circumstances for themselves....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Operative Management

Sam Walton, the founder of Wal- Mart, used to visit his stores and meet employees at different levels of activities.... al- Mart used one of the basic theories of management called 'theory of motivation'.... theory of motivation seeks to persuade efforts from management to encourage employees.... Employees are trained in Wal- Mart as merchants and not as just subordinates of seniors....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Gaming War: Medievalism in Virtual Worlds

Although Massive Multiplayer Online (Role-Playing) Games (MMOG) seem to reflect particular aspects of the theory of “just war”, some of the rules in Augustine seem to have been changed in these games (Losh 159).... One particular rule in Augustine that was changed in the World… The goal in a warfare in the “just war” theory was quoted in the writing of Elizabeth Losh as, “the ultimate objective of battle is to avoid future conflict” (Losh [6 December Gaming War: Medievalism in Virtual Worlds Answer Although Massive Multiplayer Online (Role-Playing) Games (MMOG) seem to reflect particular aspects of the theory of “just war”, some of the rules in Augustine seem to have been changed in these games (Losh 159)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Part 2 Gaming War: Medievalism in Virtual Worlds

nswer # 2: Although many of the concepts in Massive Multiplayer Online (Role-Playing) Games [MMOGs] were derived from past theories and writings, many deliberate revisions were made especially in that of Augustine's just war theory.... It opposes the principle of Augustine's just war theory as Cicero writes, “It follows that wars should be undertaken for the one purpose of living peaceably without suffering injustice” (Losh 162).... The “just war” theory does not suggest a context of discrimination in the conduct of war but only to achieve peace at the end of the battle....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Is consumerism good or bad for the world

There are negatives and positives to the theory of consumerism and this will be explained in detail below using several theories such as Maslow's theory, Herzberg's needs theory and other motivational theories as well.... Also as a result of the positive outcome brought about by consumerism to majority of the benefactors, they are motivated to put more effort in the future in order to get the same results as is explained by Vroom's expectancy theory....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

How Commanders Execute Command in Coalition Warfare

As NATO winds down its operations in Afghanistan toward the end of 2014, it strikes me that it could conveniently lead the Alliance in creating interoperability as a theory.... Both policymakers and war zone leaders must comprehend that one can either have coalition accomplices with provisos, or no coalition accomplices by any means.... Field Marshal t Slim led forces of Britain from Burma to India in one of the lesser-known yet more nightmarish retreats of World war II....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us