StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Hell Is Other People - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Hell Is Other People” the author discusses Jean-Paul Sartre’s statement which does not mean to imply that individuals should isolate themselves from others and sever all human ties but that relationships should be based on authenticity and honesty…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Hell Is Other People
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Hell Is Other People"

The fact, however, remains that while his hell is other people, it is also of his own making. This is clearly evidenced in his continued lack of authenticity, expressed in his use of double-tongue and failure to say what he means. When greeting King Hamlet in Act I, for example, he remarks in an aside, "a little more than kin and a little less than kind." Aloud, however, he greets his uncle quite courteously and does not show his true feelings. This attitude, which is typical of Hamlet and symptomatic of his "to be or not to be a dilemma," evidences the extent to which he is complicit in his own suffering.

His failure to be true to his own sentiments and confront his own feelings and beliefs plays a key role in his suffering and, indeed, makes other people hell.Nowhere does "hell is other people," hold truer than in Hamlet's complex love-hate relationship with his mother. He does not trust Gertrude and his mistrust is such that he suspects her of complicity in his father's murder. He does not have the courage, or the self-honesty, however, to confront her. Instead, he transfers his resentment of Gertrude onto Ophelia and accuses Ophelia of that which he wants to accuse Gertrude of.

This is quite clear when he tells Ophelia, "get thee to a nunnery." Ophelia has done nothing to deserve such treatment but, in Hamlet's mind, Gertrude has. The implication here is clear: his relationship with his mother is so twisted and dysfunctional in nature that it has transported him to hell. It is, not, however, a hell which is pure of Gertrude's making but one which Hamlet's own failure to be true to himself and act with any degree of authenticity has played a fundamental role in creating.

Similar to Hamlet, relationships in The Great Gatsby underscore the extent to which the type of relationships one chooses to engage in with other people rendered "hell other people." Gatsby's relations with practically all those around him are dysfunctional; he throws parties but barely makes the effort to introduce himself. Indeed, most of those who frequent his home are neither friends nor even acquaintances. At his funeral, and despite the fact that while he was alive, his parties were always full of people, hardly any attention.

Gatsby's relationship with Daisy is virtually poisoned. Not only does it lead, albeit accidentally, to Myrtle's death but it eventually leads to Wilson's descent into a hell from which he cannot escape without killing both Gatsby and himself. While, contrary to the case with Hamlet, Gatsby cannot be accused of lacking authenticity he is, nonetheless, complicit in his own death and in the hell which others push him deep within. He is responsible insofar as he chose to engage in exploitative relationships with Daisy, Tom, and Jordan - they exploited him and he used them.

The consequence was the death of three people. Indeed, in this work, hell is not only other people but other people are dead.The correlation between lack of authenticity and "hell is other people," is further established in O'Conner's "Guests of the Nation." The plot, while sharing little in common with either The Great Gatsby or Hamlet, is based on the premise that if hell is other people, then we make them thus. The English and Irish stand in sharp contrast to one another. The English soldiers/guests, reject their status as prisoners/enemies and, instead, integrate into their surroundings and live the moment as they want to live it.

They are true to themselves and, as such, do not allow others to drag them into hell. The Irish soldiers are different. They do not want to execute the Englishmen but they carry out the order nonetheless. In so doing, they fail themselves and allow their relationships with others, specifically with the two Englishman, to become a private hell. The narrator clearly expresses this when saying: "Noble says he saw everything ten times the size, as though there was nothing in the whole world but that little patch of bog with the two Englishmen stiffening into it, but with me it was as if the patch of bog where the Englishmen were was a million miles away, and even Noble and the old woman, mumbling behind me, and the birds and the bloody stars were all far away, and I was somehow very small and very lost and lonely like a child astray in the snow.

And anything that happened to me afterward, I never felt the same about again." Noble is lost to himself and others have become his hell. He is, however, responsible for this situation because he did not act in accordance with his beliefs and failed to realize his authentic being.In sum, and as this essay has tried to argue, Hamlet, The Great Gatsby and "Guests of the Nation," are illustrative examples of the veracity of Sartre's contention that hell is other people. All three works can be categorized as tragedies and the tragedies which unfold are a direct consequence of the nature of the central characters' relationship with the people surrounding them.

Other than that, the events which lead up to the respective tragedies confirm the degree to which jaundiced relationships with others can lead to deep personal suffering. Nevertheless, the central characters are complicit in their own suffering and if others made their lives hell, they did the same.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Hell Is Other People Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words, n.d.)
Hell Is Other People Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1503321-sartres-statement-hell-is-other-people
(Hell Is Other People Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Hell Is Other People Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1503321-sartres-statement-hell-is-other-people.
“Hell Is Other People Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1503321-sartres-statement-hell-is-other-people.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Hell Is Other People

Sartres No Exit

?? In his play ‘No Exit', he is determined to prove his famous argument; “Hell Is Other People” and perception that there is no God is widely unleashed.... No Exit, the Jean- Paul Sartre's play, coined the famous slogan “Hell Is Other People!... This particular play involves majorly three people who died and went to their eternal destination, the Hell.... She describes the nadirs of her immorality in the following declaration: “When I say I am cruel, I imply I can not get on devoid of making people suffer....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

How the United Nations help people around the world

Due How the United Nations Help people Around the World Founded in 1945 on the precipice of a falling world order, the United Nations came into existence as a replacement to the defunct League of Nations; an organization that had literally failed to reign in rogue governments leading to a bloody repeat of a world war, only two decades after a first.... Through its pledge to promote “economic and social progress and development for higher standards of living”, the United Nations has profoundly touched lives of millions of people across the globe (UN par....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethics Philosophy of John Stuart Mill, Jean Jean-Paulre and Nietzsch

hellip; Mill maintains that this, “the other party,” knows better than to want to and choose to exchange places with a lower being, pig or fool, basing his assertions on several reasons.... And, he claims, if the other party does not agree, it is only because he/she is incapable of understanding Mill's position and is therefore basing his/her [inferior] contention on a lack of information....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

How can health psychologists help people to improve their health

The research paper “How can health psychologists help people to improve their health?... The essay examines the crucial work performed by the health psychologists for the prevention of disease and disorder and education of physicians, nurses and the community men and women.... It presents the contribution of health psychologists with reference to the psychological models....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Free Will & Fate in Sartres No Exit

Man has the free will to choose to be free or he can be imprisoned by letting other people choose his destiny for him.... In life and in death, Estelle allows others to create her self image rather than take responsibility for her own life, this can be seen when she asks the others repeatedly how she looks and through the use of Inez as her mirror, she shows how she is still letting other people determine who she is.... n Hell as on earth, Garcin continues to leave his existence in the hands of other people....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

A change in the way you deal with other people

Relationships are a part of society and they are surrounded with delicate issues and my previous relationship has changed the way I deal with people in such A change in the way you deal with other people A change in the way you deal with other people People are the most complex creations on earth and there have been many attempts to understand their logic to no avail.... people have so many different attitudes hence the way in which one relates to those around him can constantly be affected by certain situations in his or her… Life situations are the main reasons that people change the way in which they relate to others around them....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Existential Motifs in Medieval Poetry: Insights on Therapeutic Practice from Dante's Divine Comedy

For instance, human beings would easily… This would be influenced by the fact that the human society has already trained the human beings that there is a place called hell where subsequent punishment would be done.... This is to imply that the things human beings do towards their fellow men can be compared to hell.... Subsequently, there may be a fictitious place that is referred to as hell- where the human mind and soul may visit and be punished eternally....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Does Giving Money to Poor People Really Help Them

This paper "Does Giving Money to Poor people Really Help Them?... Some of the emergencies that occur to poor people can be overcome by adequate preparation in ways of tackling them.... Giving money to poor people and country does not yield a result as it only leads to more poverty, overpopulation, and environmental degradation; policy change and better planning can only achieve the solution.... Giving money to poor people will not help due to their ever-rising population of needy people....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us