StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Nature vs Culture - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Nature vs Culture" focuses on the critical analysis of the differences between nature and culture. The connections between nature and culture are often so close that in common language, we may even go as far as saying something regarding the nature of a group of people…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Nature vs Culture"

The connections between nature and culture are often so close that in common language, we may even go as far as saying something regarding the nature of a group of people where we mean culture. In essence, for many individuals who are not too careful about the distinction between the two, nature and culture become interchangeable terms that do not necessitate a closer examination. However, the philosophical and sociological perspectives on nature and culture certainly differentiate the two and the understanding of their difference becomes vitally important for all those who are interested in sociology, anthropology, management and even history.

Considering the various sociological perspectives that can be taken about nature and culture, two stand out from the others. These are the structural-functionalist perspective and the conflict perspective both of which consider nature and culture in very different lights. To better understand how they differ and the distinctions made by them about nature and culture it would be useful to examine them individually.

First, structural functionalism is founded on the idea that society is composed of structures that are supposed to perform a certain function. In essence, both nature and culture are social structures but culture is more of a social construct than nature (McClelland, 2000). For instance, if a culture is connected deeply to the principles of monogamy it is entirely possible that the cultural elements of the society would lead to the government outlawing polygamy.

On the other hand, some cultures may permit polygamy or even polyandry and thus the socially constructed laws in that country may permit individuals to create families in that manner. However, the functionalist perspective would suggest that the role of the family unit in both cultures could be more or less the same and the role is not solely dependent on how the family is formed.

Therefore, the role of culture in the functionalist perspective would be understood by examining the function performed by culture for a given society. The role of nature becomes something which deals with the individual and the skin-bound individual may not be included in the debate on the functions of culture for society. However, the nature of the individual may function quite importantly for a person who interacts with society and thus his/her nature may cause her to seek out groups which form a sub-culture in the larger culture.

On the other hand, the conflict perspective considers the field of sociology as well as the story of all human endeavours to be the study of a class struggle between the haves and the have-nots. Karl Marx can be considered to be the founder of this perspective of society since he and many of his followers considered the conflict between the higher and lower classes to be the basis of whatever happens in society (McClelland, 2000). The conflict between men and women, children and their parents as well as workers and their employers can be considered as a part of the sociological perspective given by Karl Marx (Gordon, 1978).

When it comes to nature, the conflict perspective considers the class battle to be the natural result of how economic systems and the culture of a capitalist system functions (Bauman, Z. 2000). The greed for more economic gains keeps the upper classes in a constant battle to control the lower classes while preventing them from gaining the commanding heights of an economy. The culture, therefore, serves to perpetuate the cause of the rich while it uses the social order to keep the poor individuals in their place. Nature again serves little purpose in such a situation since the rich make it their nature to be greedy while the poor may be told that it is in their nature to be complacent and that they should remain consumers of their culture (Baudrillard, 1998).

The only way out of this perpetual state is a revolt of the poor who overthrow their masters and then consider everything they did to be evil. At the same time, the revolt may not remain true to the fundamentals and with time, the ideals of the revolutionaries may completely fizzle out. It must be noted that such a revolt may only serve to create a new social order in which those who did not have control, violently seize control and then put their former masters in the position of slaves (McClelland, 2000).

Considering these perspectives as journeys or cycles, it becomes clear that the conflict perspective describes a cycle which starts and ends with a violent revolt in which the slaves overthrow their masters to become masters themselves. Even though the social order and social systems may change rapidly in such a revolt, after the passing of the storm the structure of society with a master-slave relationship between the classes continues to exist. On the other hand, the functionalist perspective may be seen as a journey as the function performed by an element of culture may evolve with time and may even become deprecated as the culture changes and develops on the journey it takes through internal or external influences.

While the distinction of nature being concerned with the individual and culture being connected with society is quite clear in both perspectives, it remains difficult to say that nature is defined through culture. If we consider the innate nature which humans are born with, culture has little to do with it if anything at all. However, if we consider how human beings develop as individuals and how they mature to have a particular nature as adults, it can easily be said that it is directly influenced by the culture that they have been immersed into Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Nature and culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1549266-nature-and-culture
(Nature and Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1549266-nature-and-culture.
“Nature and Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1549266-nature-and-culture.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Nature vs Culture

Nature vs. Nurture

nature vs.... Nurture nature vs.... nature vs.... Nurture nature vs.... nature vs.... Many factors like relationships, friendships, gender, emotions, self-concept, parenting, culture, attachment etc can affect the sense of self development.... These developmental stages depend heavily on two factors; nature and nurture or heredity and environment.... nature and nurture can influence the physical, mental, emotional and social development of a child in different ways....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Business Articles Review

The article nature vs.... culture: A cross-national analysis of feminine culture and economic performance is a very interesting article.... A weakness of feminine culture is that people tend to be naively altruistic and sometimes get taken advantage of.... A feminine culture does not necessarily increase the participation of women in economic and social life.... It is imperative to avoid single culture approaches to solving problems among multicultural teams....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Nature vs Nurture Dilemma

The essay "nature vs Nurture Dilemma" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the nature vs Nurture dilemma.... There has been a hotly contested debate surrounding the nature versus nurture concept.... In the nurture versus nature debate, all that matters at the end of the day is the influence that an environment has on the kind of development witnessed in an organism (Woodson, 2010).... he Oak tree has developed under the force of nature....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Nature vs. Nurture

nature vs.... Nurture [Name of Student] [Name of Instructor] [Name of Course] [Date] nature vs.... Nurture Over the years, the debated contest of viewpoints regarding nature vs.... The issue of nature vs.... This paper aims to critically assess different schools of thought regarding the issue of nature vs.... have provided their in-depth addresses regarding nature vs.... These anthropologists have greatly provided three distinctive grounds of understanding the issue of nature vs....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Nature vs. Nurture Discussion

The essay "nature vs.... nature vs.... Identifying nature vs.... As one might assume, the nature vs.... culture is a set of ideas about the environment and the world, and how people should act in it that is shared--and shared unfairly--by members of a neighbourhood.... On the one hand, culture is a structure of canned recipes--cognitive and behavioural sets or algorithms of habits, --for socializing with others, allowing individuals to perform their social roles without having to make intended decisions....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Nude Art Form

When debating the female nude and its aesthetic quality from the point of nature vs.... culture and reason vs.... Descartes is emphatic that reason is male, but it needs its female counterpart, exemplified as nature and passion.... It is also unchained from the fetters of common behavior because of its apolitical and asexual nature....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Nature vs Nurture

The essay "nature vs Nurture" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the dilemma between nature and nurture.... he history of the issue of nature vs.... The stance of Galton on nativism was either supported or advocated by various other theorists and psychologists until there were two groups of psychologists – the evolutionary psychologists, who support the idea that man acts mainly based on his nature and instinct; and the cultural psychologists, who advocate the theory that man is what he is primarily because of his culture and environment (Snibbe, 2004)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Opinion on Nature vs Nurture

As such Essay, Psychology Topic: nature vs.... Nurture My opinion about nature versus Nurture is simple and straightforward.... The answer to the question of nature versus nurture is not simple; rather it is a complicated mixture of both heredity and environment.... The tussle between nature and nurture has been going on since time immemorial.... Just because more and more knowledge is gained on the subject, no one should think that we are nearing to a perfect solution to understand the working of nature versus nurture....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us