StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Soft HRM Practices Differ - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper will analyze HRM and why it is not articulating to industrial relations practices. Over the time, HRM has confronted the existence of industrial relations. Others argue that industrial relations and human resource management hold different views of similar phenomena set…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Soft HRM Practices Differ
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Soft HRM Practices Differ"

Human Resource Management Human Resource Management can be defined as the management of a workforce of an organisation or human resources. Human Resource Management is responsible for attracting, selecting, assessing, training, and rewarding the employees and ensuring that the employees are compliant with the labour laws and the guidelines managing their terms.Since the mid-80s, the introduction of HRM (Human Resource Management) has influenced employment relationships. Over the time, HRM has confronted the existence of industrial relations. Others argue that industrial relations and human resource management hold different views of similar phenomena set. This paper will critically analyse HRM and why it is not articulating to industrial relations practices. In the recent past adoption of HRM practices has been on the rise thus challenging the personnel management existing order in many organizations. A lot of questions have remained unexplained on why HRM has been dominant over the other practices of employment. Attempts to sufficiently define the role of HRM have been unsuccessful. Many scholars had to speculate if there has been anything new formed regarding the precise definition of HRM. Some view human resource management to be in direct rebellion and rejection with personnel management and industrial relations. Others on the other hand view HRM to be a repackaged form of Personnel Management (Torrington & Hall, 2005). Interestingly, there has been a considerable degree of extension and overlap between the roles, models and theories that constitute the disciplines of Personnel Management and HRM. The overlap is in support of the fact and argument that HRM is Personnel Management that has been repackaged, and there is no big change between the two. On the contrast, the HRM outcomes have not been in agreement with that of traditional Personnel management. For example, cultural controls, strategic orientations and normative concepts are absent in HRM. Many argue that the distinction between HRM and Personnel Management is on the different ways in which the theories and models they share are being deployed. A definite example that districts between the two disciplines is discourse and dialogue HRM treats labour unions (Robbins & Coulter, 2005). To the labour process theory, HRM has become a universal term describing the different employment governance approach. To define the employment management procedures, it is necessary to distinguish between HRM as a discipline and HRM as a dialogue. To reveal the actual role of HRM it is vital to carry out a definition of based in the context it operates in. In my view, HRM is a regulation mode that nurtures an accumulation capitalist regime. It is because the HRM practices were first being formulated implemented by the Western nations whose economies are capitalists in nature. It is evident that HRM is an integral force that shaped the western countries capitalist structure. That is why they have been in the forefront of advocating for the adoption of HRM practices in organizations. HRM rise over other practices like personnel management and industrial relations has only been because of the regulation by western countries like the US (Mathis & Jackson, 2003). The extent to which hard and soft HRM practices differ HRM has a significant role in many organizations. It is because the workforce comprises of people for an invaluable asset that an organization needs to exploit well to achieve goals and objectives. Two contrasting HRM theories have been formulated to tackle the employees in a company set up, namely, soft HRM and hard HRM. Many people often confuse the two diverse approaches yet they are on the extreme extends. I will demonstrate the difference margin and extend between two HRM approaches styles, soft and hard HRM. The pros and cons between the two facilitate managers to make an informed decision on the method to adopt between the two or a blend of both. It is essential to establish the fact that both soft and hard HRM have a vital significance to an organization, as such they are critical to business entities. A company will, for example, have a competitive advantage over its rivals if it uses its human resources in an efficient manner. Utilizing the expertise of a workforce and ensuring they are motivated will enable a business entity to achieve its goals and objectives (Andersen, 1999). In the late 1980s, Storey helped elaborate on the Harvard and Michigan management models on the Y and X theories to show the difference between soft and hard HRM styles. Theory X views employees as having self-interests and lazy in their duties. The approach to the theory implies that the interest of the employees and the company are completely contrasting. Furthermore, Theory X indicates that it is the role of the managers to make the employees alter their behaviour so as to meet goals. The approach by Theory X views employees as machines, and the management has a duty to force them to be productive. The theory X demonstrates the hard HRM style. On the other hand, Theory Y demonstrates the Soft style of HRM by viewing employees to be human beings with feelings, emotions and motivations. As opposed to the hard HRM style, they are not considered as machines. As such, the management of an organization must seek to motivate them since they are seen to be creative and proactive. In general hard HRM sees employees as lazy while soft HRM views employees to be responsible and hardworking. Hard HRM considers employees to be machines with no feelings and emotions and must be induced to alter their behaviour. In contrast, soft HRM is a humane style of management that has compassion for employees that seeks to motivate employees to enable achievement of organizational goals. It does not induce behaviour alteration since the workers are not being treated as machines. Hard HRM is, therefore, a complete approach in comparison with the soft HRM style (Andersen, 1999). Additionally, the hard HR management identify the need of the workforce based on the management, recruit and business accordingly. This normally involves the hiring, firing, and also moving. On the other hand, soft Human Resource Management concentrated on the employee need. This involves the roles, motivation and also their rewards. The key features for the hard HR management are short term changes such as redundancy and recruitment while the key features are strategic focus on the planning of workforce. References Andersen, T. (1999). "Hard" versus "soft" HRM: The restructuring of employment in European banking. Mathis, R., & Jackson, J. (2003). Human resource management (10th ed.). Mason, Ohio: Thomson/South-western. Patel, V., & Rana, G. (2007). Personnel management. Jaipur, India: Oxford Book. Robbins, S., & Coulter, M. (2005). Management (8th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall. Torrington, D., & Hall, L. (2005). Personnel management: HRM in action (3rd ed.). London: Prentice Hall. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Essay”, n.d.)
What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1699840-using-theory-and-examples-to-support-your-answer-critically-discuss-what-human-resource-management-hrm-is-and-to-what-extent-do-hard-and-soft-hrm-practices-differ
(What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Essay)
What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1699840-using-theory-and-examples-to-support-your-answer-critically-discuss-what-human-resource-management-hrm-is-and-to-what-extent-do-hard-and-soft-hrm-practices-differ.
“What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1699840-using-theory-and-examples-to-support-your-answer-critically-discuss-what-human-resource-management-hrm-is-and-to-what-extent-do-hard-and-soft-hrm-practices-differ.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What Human Resource Management Is And To What Extent Do Hard And Soft HRM Practices Differ

Developing and Improving the Staffing Plans

Strategic human resource management Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 1.... Selection of two challenges in human resource management and use of specific strategies in overcoming the problems 7 3.... Introduction Strategic human resource management enables an organisation to tackle the problems associated with human resource development arising due to the external and internal interference effectively.... The strategic human resource management (SHRM) is not bounded or guided by some definite of rules....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Ethical Business Practices

Discussion The characteristics of Ethics in business are as follows: Ethical decisions differ from one person to another.... The term paper "Ethical Business practices" states that in this age of globalization and industrialization, the most essential weapon that might be used by any business organization or entrepreneur is ETHICS.... In order to do so, the entrepreneur needs to offer the products and services in such types of prices to its customers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Individuals with Learning Difficulties and Autism: Ethical Issues of Use of Restraint

In other words, the key problem is to clarify to what extent is violence acceptable in modern psychiatry, and especially in the NHS.... It's necessary to differ various types of restraint.... Those and other papers, as, for example "Strategies for the management of disturbed and violent patients in psychiatric units" Council Report CR 41, are similar in their general direction towards providing better treatment to a patient, but differ greatly in details, which is to some extant explained by legal uncertainty (to...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Essential Tools and Techniques Used By Organizations to Manage the Human Resources

nbsp;  … It is therefore quite logical to say that human resource management is a very crucial and an integral part of any organization.... Core areas of hrm include the individual, the organization and the social context of work and how all of these factors shape the relations at work and result in organizational performance.... his study is an effort to analyze the essential tools and techniques used by organizations to manage the human resources in an organization and how the hrm has adapted itself to the changing economic scenario....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Audit of a Workplace as a Learning Environment

nbsp; From this paper it is clear that learning in this organization is a continuous process as many employees do not possess the required skills for effective work performance and those who are experienced need reinforcement.... This paper stresses that the organization in which audit is to be carried out is an apparel company involved with garment manufacturing....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Role of Leadership

Contextually, certain areas of improvement were highlighted in the report that could have enhanced the leadership approaches of both the companies and their respective leaders up to a certain extent.... Notably, one of the most important aspects, which has been determined in this particular report is analysing the changing business environment along with the role of leadership in executing the activities of the same....
19 Pages (4750 words) Coursework

Human Resource Management: The Concept of Strategic Fit

nbsp;… The 'fit as contingency' approach comes across as a combination of soft hrm practices from aspects of processes, practices, procedures.... The author of the "human resource management: The Concept of Strategic Fit" paper examines fit as strategic integration, fit as an ideal set of practices, fit as a contingency, fit as bundles.... rmstrong (2009) has recognized a set of best practices in MRM which can be used for attaining maximum organizational effectiveness....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Is the Knowledge Management the Real Future of HRM

(Starke 7-8) Against this background a definition of knowledge management is sought which is compared with human resource management.... DiscussIntroduction“Knowledge management is the set of practices aimed at discovering and harnessing an organization's intellectual resources.... DiscussIntroduction“Knowledge management is the set of practices aimed at discovering and harnessing an organization's intellectual resources.... DiscussionThe concept of knowledge management is becoming increasingly prevalent in academic and vocational' literature....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us