StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Central Role of Lurie in Coetzees Disgrace - Book Report/Review Example

Summary
The paper "The Central Role of Lurie in Coetzee’s Disgrace" states that the character of Mr Isaacs is shown through that Lurie after Lurie apologizes over the grief he had caused him and the wife. He is portrayed as a considerate person, as he later promises to intervene for his return at the university…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
The Central Role of Lurie in Coetzees Disgrace
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Central Role of Lurie in Coetzees Disgrace"

The Central Role of Lurie in Coetzee’s Disgrace Disgrace, by Coetzee, appears as a straightforward personal story, although it is much more examining. It explores different themes and subjects, including the delicate issue of rape, and the complex racial interactions of post-apartheid South Africa. The author presents the different themes and subjects through the character of Lurie, who appears like the focal point in developing the character of all the others. “Character development is used to vary the characterization of the dynamic character of the different characters through the course of a narrative” (Ormond 47). The author’s development of character revolves around the language, the perception and the thoughts of Lurie, who appears to direct the character associated with all the aspects of character development. This paper will discuss the central role of Lurie in the author’s development of different characters throughout the book (Coetzee 10). The book clearly presents the position of men and women as well as sex and the disgrace that comes with it. The author writes these ideas through the eyes of Lurie, where the reader is exposed to his spoken dialogue as well as the unspoken thoughts – which portray his discourse, desire and passions. Even though the novel is written in third person, the language, perceptions and the thoughts of Lurie dominate the narrative, which shows that character development for all others is filtered through that of Lurie. “However, exposure to Lurie’s person does not present intimacy; so much as it portrays his isolation. The question for the issue is whether the character of Lurie effectively works as the filtering point, to develop the context for all other characters” (Coetzee 10-17). Through the story, Coetzee represents different characters through that of Lurie. For example, he presents the position of all others – through the subjective outlook of Lurie. However, this is not entirely true; as it appears that his shallow outlook of women is what has caused his two previous divorces and his inability to connect with women. This leads to the contrast that he is one character that could not manage dealing with conscious women, pursuing to keep their ground, and those declining his sexual domination. For example, he often differed with the daughter, for she did not share in his wayward opinions. However, despite the success he finds in controlling women and manipulating their sexual life, Coetzee shows the rise of women, who prove his domination and sexual manipulation powerless. From the account, the character of women seems to develop – to become more self-directing people – through the perspective of Lurie (Coetzee 19-25). This experience is explicated through Lurie’s dealings with women, as the first few chapters introduce two of his lovers, Melanie and Soraya. These two women differ in ethnicity, age and education; the only shared characteristic is the relationship with Lurie, and his incapability to connect with their nature. Through Lurie, the reader is introduced to the encounters of prostitution, where affairs are founded on money. Through the nature of Soraya, Lurie is shown as a character who likes keeping his affairs uncomplicated. For instance, the superficial relationship between the two shows why Lurie knows nothing about the character of Soraya, who is a Muslim woman. Through the character of Lurie, the dominated character of women is developed, for example, the domination of Melanie through authority and Soraya through money. Through this domination, the disrespected nature of women in the then South African society is portrayed. Through Melanie, Lurie is depicted as a man who defines the interests and behaviors of women, through his own desires, as opposed to noticing their lack of interest in him and the absence of common interest between the men and women of that time. Lurie’s insensitivity to women, rules, ethics and law is used to join the different characters into his own. For example, Melanie and Soraya are tied onto his subjection, one for money and the other by authority (Coetzee 16-19). Through their dealings, the superficial consideration for women is presented. This is evident through the case of Melanie, as she does not seem to object to his advances, but she does not seem to consent to them either. However, his control does not exist for long, as she makes the issue public, which leads Lurie to the public hearing. Therefore, through the work of Coetzee, it is evident that the character of Lurie is one that portrays the themes of “male domination and the manipulation of sex, although women have the power to end the subjection. These are developed in the character of different women characters” (Narvaez 157). During the investigation over sexual harassment, the officials at the public trial bench are shown as pretentious people, who hold the trial to get a confession from Lurie, though he discerns their aim and fails to cooperate (Coetzee 40). Through the character of Lurie, the reader is exposed to the then justice system. After losing his job, Lurie moves to Salem, where the characters of Lucy, Bev Shaw and Petrus are portrayed through his eyes. For example, through the eyes of Lurie, his daughter Lucy is an anachronism (Coetzee 43-52). Character development through the character of Lurie shapes the entire proceedings of the investigation, his relations and association at Salem, and a sense of change to become considerate after dealing with animals for a while. This is completely true, as the different dealings throughout the account revolve around his role, as a valuable employee at the university and a knowledgeable person at Salem. However, for him to maintain his control he had to cooperate with other characters – for example the investigators over harassment, who sought to embarrass him and not offer justice to the abuse of Melanie (Coetzee 43-52). During the violent attack, where the daughter is raped, the character of the criminals is portrayed through Lurie – after they hit him unconscious. Their character as seen in his eyes, is that of violent insensitive people. Later on, the insensitive character of Bev Shaw is portrayed through the eyes of Lurie, who views him as insensitive about his sentiments about the contribution of Petrus towards the rape of his daughter. The distanced character of the daughter is portrayed through the eyes of Lurie, as one who desired to keep her distance from the father. This is depicted through the advice he is offered by Bev, requesting him to keep distance from the daughter. He gave in to the advice, resolving to spend more time with the animals (Coetzee 77). Later, the character of Mr. Isaacs is shown through that Lurie, after Lurie apologizes over the grief he had caused him and the wife. He is portrayed as a considerate person, as he later promises to intervene for his return at the university (Coetzee 171). Through the character of Lurie, Rosalind, Lurie’s ex-wife, is portrayed as a character that cares about his welfare, as he reminds him of his act of giving up his career for an affair (Coetzee 187). Through the different characters, Lurie’s sense of alienation from society is portrayed. For example, he had been displaced from his job; his home raided, and was not warmly greeted by Elaine Winter, at the supermarket. Arguably, his alienation resulted from the earlier treatment of other characters as though they were second best to him. For example, through the character of Rosalind, he is portrayed as a great self-deceiver (Coetzee 188) and according to Lucy, Lurie acted as though the lives of others formed only a part of his own (Coetzee 198). The inadequacy of his self-centered approach culminates in his loss of everything; he suffered disgrace from his selfish perspective. To the end of the account, the character of Lurie is portrayed as the central point for character development, as his dealings with the different characters are used to draw-out the characters of these other characters. For example, towards the end, Mr. Isaacs and Rosalind’s characters are portrayed through the book, as they revolved around their relations with Lurie. However, he is shown to influence their character greatly, as he still receives their favor. For example, Mr. Isaacs promises to intervene for him at the University. However, his central role in developing the other characters fades, as he is shown as an object of ridicule from all other characters by the time the story ends. For this reason, it is clear that his central role as the character that was used to develop all other characters throughout the story diminishes towards the end. Works Cited Coetzee, John. Disgrace. New York: Penguin Books, 2000. Print. Narvaez, Darcia. “Does Reading Moral Stories Build Character?” Educational Psychology Review 14. 2 (2002): 157. Ormond, Jeanne. Educational Psychology: Developing Learners. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill, 2003. Print. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Central Role of Lurie in Coetzees Disgrace

Metaphors in the Disgrace by J. Coetzee

disgrace dogs are used consistently in the book to illustrate the development of the various stylistic devices in the novel.... In the book, the dogs are used to depict a two-fold approach: the confrontation between blacks and whites, and the Lurie's disgrace.... Having divorced twice, lurie is a dissatisfied worker, initially teaching communication and later engaging in an affair with a student leading to serious consequences of the job loss....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Sexuality and Animals in Coetzee's Disgrace

The author states that sexuality and animals in disgrace describe how sex and rape hide white guilt in postapartheid South Africa.... Several black men attack them and rape Lucy, which demonstrates another point of disgrace in Lurie's life.... In disgrace, Coetzee uses animals as metaphors for the human experiences of pain and suffering because it removes white guilt and racial violence by putting it in the context of animal welfare, while his allusion to several literary works relate to sexuality because of the connection between rape and sexual desire, and the history of post-apartheid South Africa's continuing racial, gender, and class inequalities....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Significance of the Dog in J.M. Coetzee's disgrace

Coetzee's ‘disgrace' Order No.... 533779 One of the most controversial and challenging novels is Coetzee's ‘disgrace' that oozes with various implications making it rather difficult to understand.... “disgrace” by J.... Coetzee's primary theme in ‘disgrace' revolves around a man who is broken down and reduced to almost nothing, but finally searches and finds a small speck of redemption by way of his acceptance of the realities of life and death....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Coetzees Disgrace

When she lets them in, they rape Lucy in front of lurie.... But yet again that is not what implies-his point is to show the changing values in post-apartheid South Africa which are a bit like the work of lurie's Byron opera.... Coetzee's Booker prize winning novel disgrace (first published in 1999) tells the story of David Lurie, a white, 52-year-old twice-divorced adjunct professor of communications at Cape Technical University (formerly Cape Town University College), who thinks, that ''for a man of his age, 52, divorced, he has, to his mind, solved the problem of sex rather well....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of Coetzee's Disgrace

To the end of the account, the character of lurie is portrayed as the central point for character development, as his dealings with Mr.... The author writes these ideas through the eyes of lurie, where the reader is exposed to his spoken dialogue as well as the unspoken thoughts – which portray his discourse, desire, and passions.... Even though the novel is written in the third person, the language, perceptions and the thoughts of lurie dominate the narrative, which shows that character development for all others is filtered through that of lurie....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Comparison of the Novel and the Film Adaptation of Disgrace

he book yet presents at the opening the life of lurie, coming from the brothel where he meets Soraya, a prostitute he meets weekly but this arrangement falls apart soon.... This movie review "Comparison of the Novel and the Film Adaptation of Disgrace" discusses Steve Jacobs and writer Anna-Maria Monticelli who have succeeded in making a film from John Maxwell Coetzee's prize-winning novel Disgrace with John Malkovich taking the role of the main character.... In this paper, we will compare the novel disgrace and its adaptation film and try to examine their presentation of different visions of post-apartheid South Africa....
9 Pages (2250 words) Movie Review

The Theme of Power in the Disgrace Novel by Coetzee J

This paper talks about the theme of power as it plays out in the novel 'disgrace'.... Even though disgrace was applauded for being brutally honest, the realm of South Africa politics was not very receptive.... Additionally, he argues that disgrace both contests and encourages such a reading by holding immense choices in tension.... lurie is a specialist in the literature of romantic, gets catapulted into South Africa much diverse from the scenes explained in Wordsworth....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of the Novel Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee

The author of the paper analyzes the novel 'disgrace 'J.... The novel 'disgrace' looks at the effect the social and political agendas have in the creation of the identity of a person.... In the novel 'disgrace' (1999), Coetzee uses the novel's protagonist who is named David Lurie to discover the consequences that social and political change has in generating the base of individuality in a person.... The social value he carries was a great sign of 'disgrace' after the court hearing and is seen in his relationship with his daughter and divorced wife, not one but two....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us