StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Memetics: An Evolutionary Theory of Cultural Transmission - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Memetics: An Evolutionary Theory of Cultural Transmission" discusses Alvarez who outlines three dilemmas that face memetic science. The first dilemma is if a culture can be viewed as a composition of information units that are transmitted independently…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Memetics: An Evolutionary Theory of Cultural Transmission
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Memetics: An Evolutionary Theory of Cultural Transmission"

number Article analysis Introduction Richard Dawkins, in his book The Selfish Gene, describes living things such as humans as good examples of platforms for the transmission of genetic information they bear. In addition, he refers to genes as vessels of information replicators that produce exact copies of themselves in order to survive from generation to generation. In order to preserve this continuity, the replicators play the most significant role to ensure evolution carries on. Dawkins opposes Darwinian’s illustration of how human behavior is related to genetic terms and suggests that there is a unit referred to as a meme responsible for cultural transmission. A Meme plays the same role as genes and depends on imitation to produce copies of them. In his book, Dawkins states that some of the examples of memes include catch phrases, ideas, and methods of making arches or pots, tunes and clothe fashions among others (Alvarez 24). Memes make use of the process of imitation to leap from brain to brain within the meme pool, a process similar to how genes leap from body to body within the gene pool through eggs or sperms. The core aim of this paper is to demonstrate that the meme has the ability to influence the treatment of human culture and society through the study of the human being in order to bridge the gap that exists between natural and the social sciences as Alvarez describes in his piece of work. Discussion According to Alvarez, Dawkins provides two versions of definition for memes. Darwinism argument even sheds more light into its reason for existence, and other theorists’ perception towards memetics. In the version referred to as Dawkins A, a meme is a unit of imitation that leads to cultural transmission. In the version of Dawkins B, he defines a meme as a unit of information that stays in the brain. He further claims that it has the feature of a definite structure and has ability to realize the physical medium used to store information in the brain. The evolutionary psychology and sociobiology aims to change cultural behaviors through biological determinants, a move that memetics differ with. Memetics acknowledges the existence of inheritance within the human species that occurs through both mechanism; the cultural and biological inheritance. Other scientific experts maintain that the genetic domain and the socio-cultural domain have to be illustrated independently. Furthermore, Dawkins discusses universal Darwinism that contains the evolutionary principles encompass both the socio-cultural and the genetic domain. Universal Darwinism uses the strategy of abstracting strange features in organisms and genes taking into account the roles of phenotypes and genotypes. Phenotype is defined as a physiological, behavioral, or morphological feature that an organism displays due to the interaction with the environment and its genotype. On the other hand, genotype consists of genes present in an organism. Using this perspective, evolution is seen to take place in two possible processes; ecological interaction and replication (Alvarez 24). According to Alvarez, Ecological interaction is the association or relationship that exists between an organism and its environment. Replication, on the other hand, is the process where genes are transferred through copying through generations while making sure that the successive generations are alike. They should be alike in order to allow cumulative selection to happen. Ecological interaction biases the process of replication by making sure that the differences, which exist between successive generations, have the capacity to allow mutation to happen. This is the main reason why Dawkins term organisms as vehicles that house genes and the location of phenotypic effects. This makes replication the key significance of the genotypic makeup of an organism. The Darwinian principles are hence considered easier to explain the evolutionary process (Alvarez 25). The reason we have Darwinian evolutionary theory being applied in culture explanation, as written by Alvarez, is its ability to bridge the gap that exist between the social and natural sciences. Human behavior is regarded as the fruit of the interaction of the natural environment and the evolved psychological and physiological variables. This means that the human culture is determined by biological means through the species’ evolutionary history. From the evolutionary point of view, the evolutionary psychologists and socio-biologists believe that behaviors, that are common, are the consequence of the clash between instincts that date back to the Stone Age with our current technological environment and human brains. Alvarez claims that, reductionists believe that the evolutionary psychologists and socio-biologists counter the cultural selections approach that suggests the form of inheritance has a dual system within the human species. This dual system consists of the cultural transmission and genetic transmission. The whole approach is regarded as the gene-cultural coevolution. Memetics have links with cultural selectionism but differ when it comes to the mainstream co evolutionism. They differ from cultural selectionism on the ground that it insists that replication is one of the mechanisms associated with cultural inheritance. Since cultural units are said to be replicated as genes, there lies an assumption that definable units have the ability to distinguish themselves within a culture. Anthropologists have come out clear to criticize the memetic stance claiming that culture is composed of a continuum and there is the possibility of any unit within it becoming an arbitrary construct of the observer (Alvarez 25-26). On the other hand, the idea by memeticists that cultural inheritance only occurs through replication has faced criticism since replication has no links to cultural transmission. Another argument claims that the evolutionary feature of cultural transmission is not determined by an inheritance mechanism but rather depends on replication. There are suggestions that cultural transmission may be as a result of cognitive mechanisms features of the human species. The conclusion drawn from that standpoint is that memes replicate. In addition, memetics and cultural selectionism differ since the latter holds that there is a possibility of cultural transmission being a product of non-genetic transmission. Concisely, it suggests that there is a likelihood of classical conditioning, direct instruction, imprinting, observation imitation, and operative conditioning. The main reason why imitation is emphasized in cultural transmission is that it stands to be the only means of transmission that has the ability to accumulate modifications through generations. In some way, this makes imitation seem like a distinguishing character of the human species. Memetic drive is credited for the development of the humankind imitation capacity that provides answers to odd phenomena that are strange to the human species. Such include speech, non-altruistic acts, and hypertrophied brain among others (Alvarez 27). Alvarez asserts that memetics, also be referred to as the branch of mentalist or idealist technological artefacts appear to have semantic phenotypic expression of mentifacts or what is referred to as the syntactic mental entities. The main constituents of mentifacts are the genotypes that give rise to artefactual phenotypes through interaction with the environment. According to several critics, this suggestion has a serious limitation. Genetic and memetic transmissions have several underlying differences. Biologically, genes are transmitted on a one-way basis to the children from their parents but memes can be transmitted horizontally (Alvarez 26-27). This means that memes can be transmitted from the offspring to the parent. In addition, genes specify behaviors and structure of human species, which happens during development. During this process of inheritance, the genotype is transmitted and the phenotype dies. On the other hand, the transmission of a meme follows a different route. Since a meme is a phenotype, the genotype plays the role of specifying it. The entire memetic enterprise forms its basis within the extension of genetic model to the cultural domain (Alvarez 28). There is evidence that memes form a heterogeneous class of entities as one of its constituents. This makes it simpler and fast to carry out the empirical research since it entails comprising the artefacts and behaviors that are easily observable. The real memetic units referred to as the genotypic memes be identified with artifacts because of their availability for empirical study and the process of quantification. For a replicator to be termed as successful, Dawkins suggests that it has to have three major features; fecundity, longevity and copying-fidelity. For a replicator to maintain its initial pattern after undergoing through series of several copying, it has to be to observe copying fidelity. For a replicator to spread at a higher speed, it has to ensure that it maintains a faster rate of copying; fecundity. For more copies to be made, the replicator has to ensure that the replicating pattern survives longer. Conclusion In conclusion, Alvarez outlines three dilemmas face the memetic science. The first dilemma is if a culture can be viewed as a composition of information units that are transmitted independently. The second question seeks to ask whether replication can be used to explain how the units are transmitted. The last question tends to find out whether the selectionist or Darwinian approach is viable to illustrate the science of culture. The contrast between the neuromemetic, memotypic and phemotypic theories of technology is a modern form of behavioral and mentalist opposition that exist between the new cognitive and he traditional behaviorist psychology. A version of mentalism views artefacts as phemotypes. Neuromemetrics offers a clear illustration of memetic dynamics since they are in the form of memotypes and are lodged within the brain (Alvarez 28). However, this standpoint does not give an explanation for the phenotypic transmission that take place in the outer world. The externalist memetics and behavioral memetics do not take mental representations as significant since they do not have a non-verifiable character. Unarguably, the meme has the ability to influence the treatment of human culture and society through the study of human being in order to bridge the gap that exists between natural and the social sciences. Works Cited Álvarez, Asunción. "Memetics: An Evolutionary Theory of Cultural Transmission." SORITES Home Page. N.p., 15 Dec. 2004. Web. 21 Jan. 2015. 24-28. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Memetics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1674887-memetics
(Memetics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1674887-memetics.
“Memetics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1674887-memetics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Memetics: An Evolutionary Theory of Cultural Transmission

Genetics and Evolution

From his data, he was able to show that the current theory of the time, the blending theory, was incorrect.... He was interested in how the transmission of traits occurred not only in his pea plants but in people as well.... Unfortunately, most of his work and theory were not recognized until after his death (Edleson, 2001)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Looking at the Idea of Meme

The paper "Looking at the Idea of Meme" highlights that the theory of memes and memetics is an excellent way of explaining how we refine our thought process and ideology as humans.... 'Controversies in meme theory' made good points to challenge this theory however, just because something is defined in a shaky manner, does not mean that it does not exist.... Richard Dawkins tried to explain this in his theory regarding the 'meme'....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Nepotism, Genes and Relationships

A research report of an investigation with practicals based on the hypothesis of evolutionary Psychology with assessed results, that close relationships are influenced by principles of genetic variations and fitness maximization and not just by the culture and social learning.... This answers how affectional ties and dyad specific relationships influence the younger generations and their social behaviour and how nepotism plays evolutionary psychology depends mainly on a large set of hypotheses, which it tries to prove or disprove by depending on sociological and psychological practicals and researches....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Cultural Evolution : Genes / Memes: Does the idea of Meme make sense

It emerged as a result of Charles Darwin theory of evolution.... Cultural Evolution assumes directional changes, unlike Charles Darwin's theory of evolution.... cultural Evolution in it is presumption over a specified period of time, explains that cultural changes such social inequalities appear as a result of.... Examples of non-cultural impulses may include population increase and climatic modification and alteration....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Idea of Meme

This theory, the theory of memes and memetics is an excellent way of explaining how we refine our thought process and ideology as humans.... The transmission of ideas from person to person, or culture to culture.... This literature review "The Idea of Meme" aims is to look at Dawkins' theory, as well as other sources and provide further insight into the topic of the meme.... It feels that it definitely needs to be defined as a solid science but as with other sciences, it starts as an idea, then is refined into a theory, and now is in the process of being refined....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

The Theory of Charles Darwin

From the paper "The theory of Charles Darwin" it is clear that the assumption of Darwin's theory that the implicit cluster of selection forces operating on particular attributes may be partial or imperfect.... He took into consideration several assumptions currently regarded as very problematic or flawed, like the following (Hergenhahn, 2008, 301):Besides its broad influence on psychology, Darwin's theory, particularly his evolutionary theory, is presently exerting a stronger influence....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Is the Theory of Cultural Evolution Inherently Ethnocentric

This research paper "Is the theory of cultural Evolution Inherently Ethnocentric" examines whether the theory of 'cultural evolution' is inherently ethnocentric, and concludes that evolutionary theory is severely infected with ethnocentrism due to political and social agendas of the time.... von Hayek proposed a theory of cultural evolution2often regarded as one of the most significant social theories in the twentieth century.... This research paper examines whether the theory of cultural evolution is inherently ethnocentric, and concludes that evolutionary theory is severely infected with ethnocentrism due to political and social agendas of the time it emerged in, however, we didn't find ethnocentrism to be its inherent attribute....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

Meme and its Role in Culture Evolution

Further, it examines the lifecycle and stages of meme transmission, the roles meme plays in culture, how meme merge into the culture and how they evolve culture.... In general, the meme is perceived as a vehicle for transmitting cultural symbols, ideas, or practices capable of being passed through the human mind through speech, rituals, writing, or any other imitable phenomena.... unger (2000) however observes that on the contrary, the role of memes as a cultural replicator is what makes their concept special....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us