StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Bhopal Disaster in India - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Bhopal Disaster in India" describes one of the most horrible industrial accidents in history. This disaster should be a watershed in the area of environmental legislation and policy, industrial catastrophe preparedness, company liability, and prevention of accidents all over the globe. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Bhopal Disaster in India
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Bhopal Disaster in India"

Bhopal Disaster in India Introduction On 3 December of the year 1984, approximately forty-five tons of methyl isocyanate (MIC), a very dangerous gas, leaked from an insecticide factory in Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh state of India. The insecticide plant belonged to the Indian subsidiary of Union Carbide Corporation, an American firm that mined asbestos there from 1963 to 1985. During the night of 2 December 1984 (11:00 PM), as the greatest percentage of the one million Bhopal city’s inhabitants slept, a plant operator identified a small leak of methyl isocyanate gas and growing pressure in a tank the was used for storage. The security device designer known as the vent-gas scrubber used for neutralizing toxic emissions from the MIC system had been switched off three weeks earlier (Curley, 2010). Apparently, a defective regulator had permitted the mixing of one ton of water used to clean internal pipes to with 40 tons of methyl isocyanate. The coolant of a thirty-ton refrigeration unit that generally functioned as a safety component for cooling the storage tank for methyl isocyanate had been removed for use in a different part of the factory. Heat and pressure from the strong exothermic effect in the tank went on mounting. For three months, the gas-flare safety system had not been working. At about 1:00 AM of 3 December 1984, a security valve gave way releasing a cloud of methyl isocyanate gas into the air with a deafening reverberation that resounded all over the factory. The dangerous gas drifted over neighborhoods that were thickly populated around the firm causing immediate premature deaths of thousands of people (no less than 3,800), in addition to causing panic as individuals made attempts to run away from the area. Within no time, Bhopal city’s streets were filled with the dead bodies of human beings as well as birds, dogs, cows, and buffaloes’ carcasses. Soon, local hospitals were full of injured persons and the unawareness of precisely the gas involved and its effects were further compounded this crisis (Fortun, 2001). A number of epidemiological studies carried out shortly following the industrial accident revealed that the rates of mortality and morbidity among the exposed population were high. Reports from the government of Madhya Pradesh state indicated that the catastrophe took an instantaneous toll of three thousand lives, although estimates from the Indian Council of medical Research indicated that the first seventy-two hours saw the death of ten thousand individuals. During the ensuing quarter-century, fifteen thousand to twenty-five thousand people are said to have passed away owing to the effects of the poisoning. About half a million survivors have suffered from such illnesses as blindness, eye irritation, respiratory problems, among others because of toxic gas exposure. The ultimate death toll may however never be known (Curley, 2010). Later scrutiny disclosed that the catastrophe resulted from substandard safety and operating procedures at the plant, which was understaffed. People brought damage charges against the plant and as a way of ascertaining that claims emanating from the spill disaster would be dealt with fairly and quickly, the Indian government, in March 1985, enacted the Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster Act, which made the government the lone representative of the spill sufferers in legal proceedings both within India and outside. Ultimately, under the ruling of the presiding American judge, all cases were removed from the U.S. jurisdiction and placed utterly under Indian legal system much to the injured parties’ detriment. The Indian Supreme Court mediated a settlement and UCC accepted moral liability and agreed to pay the Indian government an amount of money amounting to 470 million dollars. This amount was to be distributed among the petitioners as a full and final settlement. The court concluded on this figure based on the disputed claim that only 102,000 suffered permanent disabilities and 3000 people died ((Kumar, 2004)). However, based on considerable underestimations of the number of individuals exposed as well as the long-term health effects of contact, this was a comparatively little amount. Fortun (2001) explains that soon after the spill disaster, Union Carbide Corporation started attempting to detach itself from liability for the gas leak. Its major tactic was to transfer liability to UCIL, claiming that the Indian subsidiary built and operated the plant wholly. It also made-up scenarios revolving around sabotage, which they linked to dissatisfied employees as well as formerly unknown Sikh extremist groups. However, numerous independent sources impugned this theory. American attorney filed the first multi-billion dollar lawsuit in a U.S. court on December 7, when the toxic plume had hardly cleared, marking the commencement of years of legal intrigues in which the ethical repercussion of the spill tragedy in addition to its affect on the people of Bhopal were greatly overlooked . Fortun (2001) further points out that upon announcing the compensation settlement of 470 million dollars, UCC shares rose by two dollars per share or by seven percent in value. Important to note is the fact that the liability would have exceeded ten billion dollars that UCC was worth and insured for in 1984 had compensation in Bhopal been paid at the same rate that the defendant including UCC was awarding asbestosis victims in US courts (Castleman, 1985). According to the Department of Bhopal Gas Tragedy Relief and Rehabilitation, 554,895 people who suffered injuries and 15,310 survivors of those killed had received their compensation by the end of October 2003 (Kumar, 2004). UCC has had attempts to manipulate, conceal and hold back scientific data at every turn, all to the victims’ detriment – the company refrained from stating precisely what constituted the toxic cloud that enclosed the city of Bhopal on that December night (Dhara & Dhara, 2002). The truth is, upon MIC’s exposure to 200° heat, it yields degraded MIC, which contains hydrogen cyanide (HCN), a more deadly gas. Some victims’ cherry-red color of blood and viscera were characteristic of acute cyanide poisoning, which clearly evidences the fact that the temperature of the storage tank did reach this level in the disaster. Besides, majority of the victims responded well to sodium thiosulfate administration, an efficient therapy for cyanide poisoning but not exposure to MIC (Mangla, 1989). Although UCC recommended use of sodium thiosulfate at the outset, it later withdrew the statement, which prompts suggestions that it was attempting to conceal evidence of hydrogen cyanide in the gas leak. In effect, UCC strongly denied HCN presence making it a point of speculation among researchers (Dhara & Dhara, 2002 and Anderson, 1989). Worse still, following the disaster, UCC discontinued its operation at Bhopal plant but failed to clean up the industrial site utterly. For this reason, the plant unremittingly leaks several heavy metals as well as toxic chemicals that end up into local aquifers. Sadly, hazardously contaminated water has now become an addition to the legacy that UCC left for the populace of Bhopal (Fortun, 2001 and Chander, 2001). Twenty years following the chemical leakage, over four hundred tons of industrial waste still lay on the site. People attributed the contamination of water as well as soil was blamed for the high incidences of birth defects as well as chronic health problems among the people living around that region. In the year 2004, the Supreme Court of India directed the state to supply Bhopal residents with clean water for drinking since the area’s ground water was already contaminated (Curley, 2010). According to recent scientific surveys, to date, victims of this catastrophe still to have to put up with its impacts. In 1999, s Greenpeace report indicated that this incidence led to the contamination of the site where the factory was, the neighboring land as well as ground water. In some places, mercury levels were six million times higher than projected. Wells for drinking water close to the plant suffered heavy pollution with chemicals recognized to produce genetic defects and cancers. A study conducted in the year 2002 revealed that breast milk of nursing mothers contained mercury, lead as well as organochlorites (Veenema, 2007). Conclusion The Bhopal disaster was indeed one of the most horrible industrial accidents in history. It made the name Bhopal become synonymous with industrial disasters. It killed numerous people as well as animals and left numerous others injured. As mentioned earlier, victims of this disaster still to have to endure its impacts to this day. This disaster was and should be a watershed in the area of environmental legislation and policy, industrial catastrophe preparedness, company liability and prevention of accidents, as well as the regulation of toxicity and chemicals all over the globe. Governments around the world as well as international agencies should embrace the duty of focusing on vastly applicable procedures for communal responsibility and accident prevention both in the developing nations and in advanced industrial ones. Moreover, how and where any industry is sited as well as the way in which it deals with the dangers that it poses to the people around it should be real concerns. There is also need to provide people living around such plants with information and to include them as partakers in decision-making. There is dire need for all chemical industries to work to voluntarily come up with and execute firm environmental and safety standards to see to it that there is never a repeat of this kind of tragedy. References Anderson, N. (1989). Long-term Effects of Mthyl Isocyanate. Lancet, 2:1259. Castleman, B. P. P. (1985). Appendix: The Bhopal Disaster as a Case Study in Double Standards. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. Chander, J. (2001). Water Contamination: A Legacy of the Union Carbide Disaster in Bhopal, India. International Journal of Occupational Environmental Health, 7:72–73. Curley, R. (2010). New Thinking about Pollution. New York: The Rosen Publishing Group. Dhara, V.R. and Dhara, R. (2002). The Union Carbide Disaster in Bhopal: A Review of Health Effects. Arch Environ Health, 57:391–404. Fortun, K. (2001). Advocacy after Bhopal. Chicago, University of Chicago Press. Kumar, S. (2004). Victims of Gas Leak in Bhopal Seek Redress on Compensation. Bmj, 329:7462. Mangla, B. (1989). Long-term Effects of Methyl Isocyanate. Lancet, 2:103. Veenema, T. G. (2007). Disaster Nursing and Emergency Preparedness: For Chemical, Biological, and Radiological Terrorism and Other Hazards. New York: Springer Publishing Company. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Bhopal Disaster in India Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Bhopal Disaster in India Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1771021-bhopal-disaster-in-india
(Bhopal Disaster in India Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Bhopal Disaster in India Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1771021-bhopal-disaster-in-india.
“Bhopal Disaster in India Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1771021-bhopal-disaster-in-india.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Bhopal Disaster in India

Introduction to Risk Assessment - Hazard Identification

One of the pesticides plant in Bhopal, india caused a catastrophic accident.... Most of the time we relate risk to natural disaster, which is unpredictable and we are unable to identify the major destructions happed after this.... Most of the time we relate risk to natural disaster, which is unpredictable and we are unable to identify the major destructions happed after this.... This disaster also affected 100,000 people who suffered from different diseases at a later stage....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Int'l Business

Though the factory was given clearance for environment safety however, considering the overall culture of india, it may not have been done entirely based on the merits of the inspection.... 1) One of the key issues to be dealt within such situation would be to prepare for disaster management wherein the management of Union Carbide must have developed an alternative plan to deal with such incidents.... As mentioned in the case that there will be no double standards and all the safety and security requirements will be fulfilled suggest that the overall implications may not be as sever as they were in case of bhopal....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Environmental Laws and Regulations

This is a pittance since it occurred in india and would have run into several billions if it occurred in the USA.... It has been proven time and again that compliance to laws is more economical than paying the penalties for an environmental disaster.... From mega disasters like the bhopal Gas Tragedy or the Exxon Valdez oil spill, to the individual whose automobile violates emission norms, every one has to pay a price.... The bhopal Gas Tragedy (dubbed as ‘Hiroshima of the Chemical Industry'), which killed more than 2000 and injured over 300,000 people, cost Union Carbide $500 millions (Pratima, 1998)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethics and Governance

Examples of these include the Bhopal Disaster in India, Nestlé in Africa and Coca-Cola in Colombia.... The paper "Ethics and Governance" aims to analyze Friedman's article "The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits" in which he describes businessmen as unwitting puppets of the intellectual forces that have been undermining the basis of a free society....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

In the Process Safety Standard, OSHA placed new requirements on the prime/subcontractor relationship

OSHA implemented these changes for a variety of reasons, but perhaps one of the most notable is the bhopal disaster that took place in Bhopal, India on December 2, 1984 at the Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL) pesticide plant.... Among these requirements, employers are required to:Create and maintain written safety information that includes the chemicals, equipment and technology used in each individual processPerform a workplace hazard estimation of potential disastrous consequencesKeep employees up to date with the hazard evaluationsCreate a system of response to the hazard evaluationsOccasionally go over the workplace hazard evaluation system itselfCreate and employ written operating procedures for each step of a chemical processProvide the written safety and operational procedures for employees with emphasis on each hazard and its subsequent safe practice procedureAssure that prime and subcontractors have the correct information and training for the workplaceEnsure that all employees and contractors are trained in emergency response procedures pursuant to section 126(d) of the Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization ActCreate a quality assurance procedure that ensures consistency with design specifications of all equipmentCreate and employ maintenance procedures, training, inspection and testing of any and all critical process equipmentPerform pre-use safety inspections of all new or modified equipmentInvestigate any and all incidents that could have resulted or did result in a major accident, with amendments to said procedure made if neededOSHA implemented these changes for a variety of reasons, but perhaps one of the most notable is the bhopal disaster that took place in Bhopal, India on December 2, 1984 at the Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL) pesticide plant....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Management Accounting in Support Decision Process

Bradford explains that for Such was the extent too great that when a week after that more than 8000 other people died with gas related ailments which were also attributed to the disaster in the same period (Ingrid 2001).... Some of the main management accounting issues that can be learnt from this prior to the disaster happening can mainly be attributed the fact that the courts found the management of the UCIL(Union Carbide india Limited), the parent company responsible to be liable for negligence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Bhopal Union Carbide Tragedy

Leaking into the slums residential area of Bhopal, india,… (BBC, “1984: Hundered Die in Bhopal Chemical Accident”) Even animals were not spared as cats, dogs, and birds, littered the streets -- lifeless.... Leaking into the slums residential area of Bhopal, india, more than 20 thousand people died from the effects of chemical exposure while over 3 thousand required medical treatment.... Rather, Union-Carbide india was owned and operated by the Indian company of the same name....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Bhopal Gas Disaster

he Union Carbide india was a company that produced carbonyl pesticide, which is an intermediate product of methyl isocyanate.... The paper "The Bhopal Gas disaster" discusses that the incident occurred on 3 December 1984 and more than 2,259 people died within hours.... hellip; The occurrence of a similar incident to the bhopal gas leak may be disastrous to the city of Preston.... It resulted in massive amounts of poisonous gases been released into the bhopal which in turn resulted in many people waking up with burning sensation in their lungs....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us