StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical reading response - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Subject Professor Date School is Bad for Children John Holt, in his article entitled “School is Bad for Children,” discusses how the traditional education system does not aid in truly educating children. Holt declares that upon entering school, the inherent learning drive of kids is diminished at a great level…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Critical reading response
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical reading response"

Download file to see previous pages

He offers three possible solutions for these issues. He states that mandatory attendance should be abolished and replaced with policies allowing kids to attend classes only when they want to. He also suggests removing children from schools, declaring them to be prisons where learning is limited. Additionally, he views that abolishing the curriculum is also a possible solution because people merely remember what they believe is interesting and useful to them. In order to assess the veracity or, at least, appropriateness of Holt’s claims, the major points of his article will be analyzed.

First, Holt states that learning is inherent in every human, and that babies learn the basics of living and survival from the day they are born. Without any formal instruction, kids learn to communicate and interact with people around them. They learn through discovery, association, application, and mistakes (Holt, “School is Bad for Children”). This is a very strong point. Yes we should acknowledge that school provides specialized information of some subject matters, but it does not mean that learning the same is impossible outside school.

To prove this, one can simply look at the greatest minds in man’s history like Albert Einstein, Blaise Pascal, Pierre Curie, the Wright brothers, Thomas Alva Edison, and Alexander Graham Bell. These great minds did not acquire their knowledge from traditional schools because they were all home-schooled (McKee 16). Therefore, with the undeniable inherent ability of man to learn coupled with proven achievements of those that never went to school, it is easy to agree with Holt on this matter. Another statement made by Holt is that school environment encourages passive learning, thereby decreasing the utilization of man’s inherent ability to learn through active discovery, association, application, and mistakes.

It also encourages the thinking that to be wrong is a crime, and to be right is the only acceptable thing. In school, students are dictated by the experts on what is important, what they need, and what they should do. Technically, everything is spoon-fed (Holt, “School is Bad for Children”). Holt is not exaggerating when he states school teaches kids to do something only if they are forced, bribed, or deceived, since school rewards excellence and correctness. Despite the idea that teachers encourage children to analyze and ask, at the end of the day, they still follow a pre-set standard of what is correct and incorrect.

Knowing the correct and universally accepted answer is the only way to pass, and passing is the only way to move forward. These standards place children in categories --- stupid, average, or brilliant (McKee 21). Moreover, it gives a false idea that learning and living are separate things that cannot merge together. The live outside the school, and learn inside with the experts. It reinforces the belief that children cannot be trusted to learn on their own --- they need experts to tell them what they should know to be considered knowledgeable and learned (Holt, “School is Bad for Children”).

Holt again presents unquestionably strong arguments on this matter. Everyone who experienced school can relate to a great chunk of Holt’s standpoints. Another controversial statement is Holt’s declaration that schools shut kids’ brains and lead them to vices, particularly drugs. Several people may react negatively

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical reading response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1415752-critical-reading-response
(Critical Reading Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1415752-critical-reading-response.
“Critical Reading Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1415752-critical-reading-response.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical reading response

Critical Incident Analysis Case Study

It is difficult to define and is a nonspecific response of an organism to any demand placed up on it.... In case of Jane's mother, Jane's complaint of pain and no pain medication given in response to it threatened to overwhelm her ability to cope, and it produced an inordinately strong emotional, cognitive, and behavioural reactions in her.... Theoretically, factors that can influence a person's response to an extraordinary situation includes a history of psychological impairment, personal values, the manner in which...
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

Improving responses of students with autism

In the paper “Improving responses of students with autism” the author analyzes the topic of autism and the effects of various learning factors on ASD children.... The lack of social skills and children's failure to communicate with others is the determining feature of the disorder itself....
25 Pages (6250 words) Research Paper

Cognitive Manipulations on Physiological Networks

According to the cited research, appraisals are a person's beliefs about the ability to deal with a situation based on available resources, and they can lead to a challenge response or a threat response.... A challenge response occurs when we believe that we have enough resources to address the situation, and may have beneficial cognitive and cardiovascular benefits.... However, a threat response due to an appraisal of insufficient resources may cause damages that are associated with stress....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Reading Response Paper

y response and Reflection I have never read the book that the author wrote and read from.... The response of his audience and readers was enough to empower him to craft another one.... His voice was moderately loud but he spoke so clearly and knew… Although he did not change his voice too much to fit the characters, the audience had no problem figuring out who he was talking about because he incorporated some quirks of the character's personality in his reading of a condensed portion of “The Art of Fielding” by the Chad Harbach The reading The audience had the pleasure of listening to a reading of the author's book, “The Art of Fielding” (Harbach, 2011)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Reading response

critical reading response: What audience is the writer writing for, and what is the writer's purpose for writing?... From Fowles, emotional appeal in advertisements is a deliberate move to satisfy urges and desires not evident in the consumer's skeptical and cautious abilities founded on Mengjie Zhang Mills English 1A 10-31 reading response Comprehension response Jib Fowles evaluates the magic in advertisements that prompts the human mind to set an advert apart and define is as attractive and gives it attention....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Reading response

critical reading response Where has the writer used effective—or ineffective—organization, style, evidence, or argumentation?... He then goes further to explore the differences in advert by looking at different Mengjie Zhang Mills English 1A 10-4 reading response Comprehension response The explores how advertisers used gender based adsin order to attract buyers.... Essay connection response: Are men and women intrinsically different?...
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Why the modern world is bad for your brain by Daniel J Levitin

Levitin argues that email overload compounded with response-time pressure has become a serious problem and costs us time and health.... When I am doing a reading for an assignment, for example, simultaneously I check and respond to emails, instant messenger, answering my phone, and sometimes listening to my favorite music too.... This article is both critical and thought-provoking on the widespread tendency to allow technology to take over one's life by becoming addicted to multitasking....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Critical Evaluation of McGuire and Botvinick's Study

The study "Critical Evaluation of McGuire and Botvinick's Study" has critically examined the connection between decision-making processes and cognitive response by different human characters.... This principle means that in order to make deter decisions, the brain will require advanced cognitive and response efforts....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us